A comparison of clean energy storage solutions

Exploring energy storage innovations for a sustainable future

Hydrogen technologies
Credit: Pixabay

In the pursuit of sustainable energy systems, the choice of clean energy storage solutions plays a crucial role. This article compares three energy storage solutions with which we are familiar due to our involvement in projects: Lithium-Ion Batteries, Vanadium Redox Flow Batteries (VRFBs), and Green Hydrogen. We will assess their carbon footprint, advantages, disadvantages, and applications to understand their suitability for various energy storage needs.

Lithium-Ion Batteries

Lithium-ion batteries are a form of rechargeable battery that stores energy by reversibly inserting Li+ ions into electrically conducting solids. They are widely recognised for their high energy density, making them suitable for electric vehicles, consumer electronics, and renewable energy storage applications. However, their production and disposal contribute to a moderate carbon footprint. Despite their advantages, lithium-ion batteries face challenges such as high costs, safety concerns, and limited lifespan, particularly in the context of large-scale energy storage needs.

Notable companies

Tesla: a renowned American electric vehicle and clean energy company, founded in 2003 by Elon Musk. Tesla is a pioneer in electric vehicles and renewable energy products, including innovative lithium-ion batteries used for energy storage in residential, commercial, and utility-scale applications.

Panasonic: a prominent Japanese multinational electronics corporation, established in 1918. Panasonic is a key player in the lithium-ion battery market, supplying high-quality batteries for electric vehicles, consumer electronics, and energy storage systems.

Vanadium Redox Flow Batteries (VRFBs)

VRFBs offer a compelling alternative for large-scale energy storage solutions due to their low carbon footprint. These batteries exhibit notable advantages such as low cost, high efficiency, and scalability. However, VRFBs have limitations including lower energy density, complexity in system design, and comparatively lower power density. Despite these challenges, VRFBs are well-suited for applications requiring robust, long-term energy storage, especially for renewable energy. VRFBs excel in terms of their carbon footprint, with only 66% of the global warming potential of lithium-ion competitors.

Notable companies

Invinity Energy Systems: a leading provider of vanadium redox flow batteries (VRFBs) designed for grid-scale energy storage. Based in the UK, Invinity offers high-performance, long-duration energy storage solutions that enhance the reliability and flexibility of renewable energy systems.

Bryte Batteries: a Norwegian startup specialising in vanadium redox flow batteries (VRFBs) for grid-scale energy storage. The company focuses on delivering cost-efficient and scalable VRFB solutions to support renewable energy integration and grid stability.

Green Hydrogen

Green hydrogen is a clean and versatile energy source made through electrolysis using renewable inputs like solar or wind power. It’s emerging as a technology for seasonal renewable energy storage. While batteries are effective for short-term storage (e.g., hourly/daily), hydrogen storage can manage longer-term energy needs, addressing seasonal supply variations. Green Hydrogen has potential applications across commercial, industrial, and mobility sectors. However, challenges like high production costs, low efficiency, and complex infrastructure limit its widespread adoption.

Notable companies

Ballard Power Systems: a leading provider of hydrogen fuel cell technology, established in 1979 and headquartered in Canada. The company develops innovative hydrogen fuel cell solutions for transportation, stationary power, and backup power applications.

Dumarey Hydrocells: a unit of a Belgian group specialising in the design of green hydrogen solutions. It focuses on increasing the economic sustainability of the hydrogen value chain with a particular emphasis on green hydrogen production, storage, and distribution optimisation.

Other energy storage solutions

In addition to the discussed technologies, there are several other energy storage solutions contributing to the sustainable energy landscape:

  • Pumped Hydro Storage: Utilises water reservoirs to store and generate electricity
  • Compressed Air Energy Storage (CAES): Stores energy by compressing air underground
  • Thermal Energy Storage: Stores heat or cold for heating and cooling applications
  • Flywheel Energy Storage: Uses kinetic energy stored in spinning rotors

Each of these solutions offers unique benefits and applications, contributing to the diversity and resilience of modern energy systems.

Energy storage solution carbon footprint

In the pursuit of sustainable energy solutions, the selection of appropriate energy storage technologies is paramount. This table provides an initial comparison of three energy storage solutions we focus on here:

Energy Storage Solution Carbon Footprint Applications
Lithium-Ion Batteries Moderate Electric vehicles, consumer electronics, renewable energy storage
VRFBs Low Large-scale energy storage solutions, renewable energy storage
Green Hydrogen Low Commercial, industrial, and mobility purposes

By comparing these and other attributes, stakeholders can make informed decisions about which energy storage solution best aligns with their specific project requirements and sustainability objectives.

Final thoughts

Industry leaders and innovative startups in these sectors are driving advancements and adoption, paving the way for a cleaner and more sustainable energy future. Understanding the strengths, limitations, and applications of various energy storage technologies is essential for making informed decisions and accelerating the transition towards renewable and resilient energy systems.


To learn how we can help your business explore or invest in these new technologies:

Business services


P27 Team

View posts by P27 Team
A cadre of associates that deliver short consultations and project-based business services to both SMBs and larger businesses. Their expertise includes business change, business development, business planning, digitisation, ESG integration, financial markets, green finance, leadership development, marketing, regionalisation, risk management, valuation and more.
Scroll to top